Above average food. Sea food tower was good, small lobster tail. Escargot was very good. Main dish: grouper was 4/5. Tile fish was slightly overcooked. Key-lime pie was 4/5. Service was 5+++ /5, 5/23/24 - Pierre's is a nice restaurant in a beautiful location. The menu is creative and well executed. Pictured are our appetizers of shrimp cocktail and lobster ravioli which were both good though a little different than what we expected. I had the duck breast for my entree and my wife had mahi mahi with crab. Both were very good. We split a molton lava cake for dessert and really enjoyed the orange puree that it was served with though I didn't care for the sour cream on top (yes, sour cream not whipped cream 😲). It was a good meal in a beautiful setting., I’ve been coming to this place for years! Little paradise on earth, best views and spectacular sunsets! Great parking. Plenary of seating, the place is huge! Has covered seating too, if it rains. Food is good, service is a bit slow, but who is in a rush?! - you are in paradise! Relax! This time we were lucky enough to catch an evening performance and we had a blast! Definitely a must visit, if you are in islamorada or on your way to Key West, My boyfriend and I came here on February 10 for dinner, and had an unforgettable experience. First off, my boyfriend decided to propose before dinner. We can’t thank the server enough that he talked to who took a video and photos for us before the restaurant got busy. I believe it was the manager that was waiting for us near the main entrance with champagne as we walked back from the stage area. Service and food was incredible for such a special moment in our lives! Forever will be a place we visit when we head to Florida again. Thank you Pierre’s staff for outstanding hospitality!, Mahi Mahi, Roe, Black Olive Mashed Potatoes, Aparagus and Cherry Tomatoes. Unbelievable flavor and texture. Most delicious meal EVER. Service was a bit uneven, however, the extraordinary meal was the show!