If you are thinking of a restaurant to try, this place is an ABSOLUTE MUST!!! It is a cute restaurant with the most delicious freshly cooked food! I had the fish special (grouper) with pink shrimp and my SIL had the yellowtail fish dinner. Both were perfectly cooked and finger licking good! Oh and I can not forget the yummy caprese salad we shared and our dessert...The Best Key lime pie in Key West! And YES they do deliver on it!! Last but not least, the service and hospitality was top notch!! I would definitely recommend!!, Red Shoe Island Bistro in Key West offers an intimate dining experience with attentive service and outstanding cuisine. The grouper, served with a creamy sauce and garnished with fresh herbs, stood out as the highlight of the meal, surpassing even the fish of the day in flavor and presentation. The evening was capped with a phenomenal key lime pie, a perfect balance of tart and sweet, beautifully presented with a dollop of whipped cream and a slice of lime. The cozy atmosphere, combined with the exceptional food and service, made for an unforgettable dining experience., "Casual" Fine dining in Key West. Do not pass this place up. The owner is obviously very passionate about delivering the best experience possible. Best key lime pie on the island at the time of this writing. Not overly sweet, not acidic or tart. House made whipped cream! Wonderful fresh food and kind people., Wow. Simple quality ingredients with imaginative cooking brings amazing dishes. The deviled eggs with scallops are one of the best dishes I had in recent years. We had the sharing lobster bake appetizer which was good. Main we had the seafood medley (pasta dish) which my better half said (out of the park) dish. I had the scallops main which came with spinach ricotta tower- excellent dish although a bit heavy if you try to finish the cheese. We shared their key lime pie for dessert. I am not a fan of key lime pie because it is served in many places across the country and it is usually mediocre at best. Well NOT here, it’s a personal slice that we shared but we will come back for it as it was delicious. Btw, the men’s bathroom has a boombox playing and the women’s has a record player. One note, they don’t have an espresso which would have ended the dinner perfectly. Highly recommended., Really really good Food. I guess one of the best restaurants in the key West. However the portions are to small. The starters were ok but the main courses are to small. Even after sharing 2 starters(8 pieces). The salad was a joke and should not have been approoved by the the Waiter as a main course. Hopeless! The dessert were ok - if it was the best pie in the Keys as promissed I do not know. The decoration on the toilets are brilliant. The waiter was so Nice and “on”. Paid 250 for 4 People without Wine.